An interventional study of en-bloc resection and piecemeal resection in Colorectal Adenoma With Mild Dysplasia, Colorectal Adenoma With Severe Dysplasia and Colorectal Adenomatous Polyp, sponsored by Universitätsklinikum Hamburg-Eppendorf. Terminated at 6 sites in 2 countries. Open to participants aged 18 Years and older. Per ClinicalTrials.gov, last updated 2023-06-29.
Sponsored by Universitätsklinikum Hamburg-Eppendorf · Not applicable, Interventional, and Treatment
Currently, colonoscopy is the safest way to detect bowel tumors and polyps, since these can be biopsied and removed in one working process. If the size of adenomas is larger than 2 cm, resections are usually done in a hospital setting. For the resection of large adenomas, different approaches can be used. The so-called piecemeal resection is done with snares, to cut off parts of the adenoma piece by piece until the whole adenoma is resected. This technique is the standard therapy, but is not required for very large adenomas, which can often show cell alterations that indicate cancer. Therefore these adenomas should be resected in one piece. This is done by the so-called en-bloc resection. For this kind of therapy, different endoscopic knifes are use to cut off the adenoma as a whole. Both resection techniques are done usually by previous injection of saline or other liquids to elevate the lesion from its bottom tissue.
Although the piecemeal resection of large adenoma is the standard therapy, it shows recurrence rates of 10 to 25%, which afford repeated therapies and follow up controls. En-bloc resections, though, are expected to have less recurrence rates but are much more complex to perform. They have higher complication rates especially in the West, where it has bee introduced only a couple of years ago.
The data situation regarding safety and efficacy of both therapies is low. This study is the first one ever to compare piecemeal EMR and ESD in a randomized way. The study might have influence on the logistics of future adenoma processing and patient flow.
In 20 to 35% of colonoscopies due to symptoms or for prevention polyps, so-called adenoma, are found. Currently, colonoscopy is the best way to detect bowel tumors and polyps, since these can be biopsied and removed in one working process. If the size of adenoma is larger than 2 cm, resections are usually done in a hospital setting. Foremost for flat adenoma, the resection by snares piece by piece, the so-called piecemeal polypectomy, or piecemeal endoscopic mucosal resection (EMR), is state of the art. Resection will usually follow a submucosal saline injection (saline assisted polypectomy). Recurrences occur in 10 up to 25 %, requiring a reapplication of endoscopic therapy and follow up examinations.
Depending on the size of adenoma, increasing amounts of cell alterations of an advanced stage such as high grade dysplasia / intraepithelial neoplasia (HGIN) up to early cancer are found. In these cases, for histo-pathological and oncological reasons, a resection in a solitary manner (en-bloc resection) is necessary to evaluate the completeness of resection properly. Also, former studies showed that recurrence rate could be decreased considerably by en-bloc resections, since the aim is to perform a complete resection basally and laterally. New endoscopic techniques of en-bloc resections have been introduced since a couple of years, using several endoscopic knifes to cut adenoma down after submucosal injection of liquid and consecutively dissect it from the tissue underneath. This technique is mostly called endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD), and, with not too large adenoma, can be combined with snare resection, too. The complexity of this method though is much larger than that of snare resection. Therefore, the western success rate is considerably less than in Japan, where it was developed first, and where higher numbers of cases exist in the upper GI tract as well as in the lower GI tract. All in all, the complication rate of en-bloc resection is higher than that of snare resection. Those complications, mostly perforations, are endoscopically controllable in most cases, though.
In comparison with Japan, Korea or China, early malign lesions oft he upper GI tract in the West are rare. Therefore, this study will be conducted on (colo)rectal lesions, which appear much more often in the West.
All in all, for efficacy (resection in total, number of recurrences) and risk (perforations), there is an indistinct data situation between piecemeal resection (EMR) and en-bloc resection (ESD). Up to now, no randomised comparing data exist. The planned study is the first randomised study between ESD and piecemeal EMR at all, since there are no studies been done for the upper GI tract, either. For reasons of complexity, ESD will conceivably remain a method for specialized centers, while piecemeal polypectomies are done in numerous hospitals. Therefore, the outcomes of this study will have influence on future logistics in polypectomies and flow of patients with large colorectal adenoma.
Piecemeal resection will be done by snare following marking and submucosal injection of saline or equivalent liquids. Small leftover adenoma tissue will be resected thoroughly by snare or forceps. High resolution endoscopes are mandatory.
After three months, an Argon plasma coagulation (APC) therapy will follow any piecemeal resection, if necessary, another resection of leftover adenoma will be done. This second session can be done by sigmoidoscopy.
En- bloc resection is done after marking by use of different customary endoscopic knifes including combining devices as hybrid knife to cut down the lesion. After submucosal injection of liquid (saline or equivalent) to elevate the tissue it will be dissected and removed by a snare of adequate size solitarily. Since the aim of this method is the total resection basally and laterally, only one session is intended.
Follow-up care: sigmoidoscopy after 6 and 18 months, colonoscopy after 36 months each after the end of the primary therapy session(s). Diagnostics will be done endoscopically and histologically of at least 6 biopsies if the size of lesion was up to 3 cm, and of at least 10 biopsies for larger lesions.
657 studies on the registry are indexed under Adenoma; 98 are open to participants now.
This study's enrollment of 110 is below the median of 250 across 412 interventional studies indexed under Adenoma.
Browse Adenoma studies →Universitätsklinikum Hamburg-Eppendorf is the lead sponsor of 403 studies on the registry; 83 are open to participants now.
Counted across the registry records on this site, refreshed daily.
Exclusion Criteria:
En- bloc resection is done after marking by use of different customary endoscopic knifes including combining devices as hybrid knife to cut down the lesion. After submucosal injection of liquid (saline or equivalent) to elevate the tissue it will be dissected and removed by a snare of adequate size solitarily. Since the aim of this method is the total resection basally and laterally, only one session is intended.
Procedure: en-bloc resection
Piecemeal resection will be done by snare following marking and submucosal injection of saline or equivalent liquids. Small leftover adenoma tissue will be resected thoroughly by snare or forceps. High resolution endoscopes are mandatory. After three months, an APC therapy will follow any piecemeal resection, if necessary, another resection of leftover adenoma will be done. This second session can be done by sigmoidoscopy.
Procedure: piecemeal resection
En- bloc resection after marking by use of different customary endoscopic knifes including combining devices as hybrid knife to cut down the lesion. After submucosal injection of liquid (saline or equivalent) to elevate the tissue it will be dissected and removed by a snare of adequate size solitarily.
Also known as: endoscopic submucosal dissection, ESD
Piecemeal resection is done by snare after marking and submucosal injection of saline or equivalent liquids. Small leftover adenoma tissue will be resected thoroughly by snare or forceps. After three months, an APC therapy will follow any piecemeal resection, if necessary, another resection of leftover adenoma will be done.
Also known as: piecemeal polypectomy, piecemeal endoscopic mucosal resection, piecemeal EMR
success rate of complete resection
success rate is confirmed by endoscopical diagnostics as well as histological diagnostics (at lest 6 biopsies in lesions up to 3 cm size, at least 10 biopsies in larger lesions). Patients with no complete resection will be treated further according to clinical requirement, depending on histology.
Time frame: 6 and 18 months after primary therapy
en-bloc group: rate of R0 resections
This parameter is regarding histopathology. Since piecemeal resections do not allow such a diagnosis, this parameter is only for the en-bloc resected group.
Time frame: timeline 0, day of en-bloc resection
recurrence rate after complete adenoma resection
Since early recurrences can evolve from leftover tumor cells and will become manifest after a time, the third control after two controls with negative biopsies.has been chosen to be the gold standard.
Time frame: 36 months after initial resection
progress of therapy in patients with incomplete resection and recurrences
patients will be treated further according to treatment standard depending on endoscopical and histological findings
Time frame: 36 months after initial resection
differences in the subgroups of adenomas
size, shape according to nice classification, low-grade and high grade intraepithelial adenomas, sm1 carcinomas
Time frame: 5 years
required time for the initial procedure
for piecemeal resections including second procedure with APC therapy
Time frame: timeline 0, day of initial resection
complications including success of complication management
rate of complications that need intervention, e.g. * perforation (intra - and post procedural, surgery, additional procedures such as antibiotics, monitoring, intensive care * secondary haemorrhage (second look endoscopy, surgery) * infection
Time frame: 5 years
complications through patient sedation
depending on sedation standards of the participating centers
Time frame: timeline 0, day of initial resection
resolution of tumor board for post resections and outcomes of patients with carcinoma histology
patients with carcinoma histology will be discussed by a of tumor board
Time frame: 5 years
Plan to share: No
This study is terminated, as verified in Jun 2023. You cannot join it, but the record below documents what was studied.
Get an email when the registry record changes — status, dates, results — or when someone posts here.
Sign in to followQuestions and observations about this study, from anyone following it. Not medical advice, and not a channel to the study team — their contact details are on the registry record.
Sign in to join the discussion. Reading takes no account; posting does. You choose a display name, and a pseudonym is the default.
Nothing here yet. If you are running this trial, taking part in it, or weighing whether to, this is the place to say so.
Universitätsklinikum Hamburg-Eppendorf