ClinicalTrials.gg
CompletedNCT03972553Updated Dec 4, 2023

Parastomal Hernia Repair Utilizing the Retromuscular Sugarbaker Versus Keyhole Mesh Techniques

An interventional study of Sugarbaker technique for repairing parastomal hernia and Keyhole technique for repairing parastomal hernia in Parastomal Hernia, sponsored by Clayton Petro. Completed at 1 site in United States. Open to participants aged 18 Years and older. Per ClinicalTrials.gov, last updated 2023-12-04.

Sponsored by Clayton Petro · Not applicable, Interventional, and Treatment

How we know

Help build ClinicalTrials.gg — short surveys, remote interviews or testing, in your language. Take part →

Phase
Not applicable
Study type
Interventional
Enrollment
150
Allocation
Randomized
Ages
18 Years and older
Sex
All
01

Study summary

This will be a randomized controlled trial comparing the incidence of radiographic hernia recurrence 2 years after parastomal hernia repair utilizing the retro-muscular Sugarbaker technique compared to the retro-muscular keyhole mesh technique. The primary endpoint will be recurrence at two years. Secondary endpoints will be the incidence of mesh-related complications, all 30-day complication rates, and hospital length of stay. Patients eligible for the study will be 18 years or older with a parastomal hernia that requires open repair retromuscular repair without ostomy reversal as determined by one of five hernia surgeons who will participate in this study at the investigators' institution. All patients will be marked for a new stoma site preoperatively. Patients who have insufficient bowel length suitable for either technique will be excluded intraoperatively. Patients enrolled in the study will be entered in the Americas Hernia Society Quality Collaborative database by the attending surgeon. The database houses patient demographics, medical comorbidities, operative details, and postoperative outcomes - all entered by the attending surgeon.

Read the detailed description

Recent estimates approximate that 120,000 ostomies are created yearly, with an overall prevalence greater than 800,000. Parastomal hernia formation is the most common complication thereof, as most reviews acknowledge a rate of 50%, which increases to 75% for patients with a waist circumference >100cm. As patients live longer and rates of obesity climb, the sequelae of parastomal hernias do as well, including difficulty fitting stoma appliances, parastomal skin breakdown, pain, and obstructive episodes - all negatively impacting the patient's quality of life and compelling them to seek repair.

Recent data from the Americas Hernia Society Quality Collaborative (AHSQC) - a quality improvement hernia registry of surgeon-entered patient demographics, operative details, and outcomes - found that only 22% of stomas were reversible at the time of their parastomal hernia operation.[7] So in the vast majority of cases, the surgeon must decide the optimal technique for repair in the presence of a persistent stoma. Decision-making includes open versus laparoscopic approaches, stoma re-siting versus leaving it in situ, use of mesh, and mesh orientation relative to the bowel. The same AHSQC analysis found that mesh is used in 94% of repairs, and almost 80% are repaired open, likely due to the need for repair of a concomitant midline incisional hernia that frequently exists. As a high-volume hernia center, the investigators' preference has been to perform an open retromuscular repair with a transversus abdominis release (TAR) and retromuscular mesh placement, allowing for reinforcement of the midline, stoma, and prior stoma site if the stoma was re-sited. The stoma can be brought through a keyhole incision in the retromuscular mesh. The investigators' hernia recurrence rate at just 13-months mean follow-up was previously found to be 11%. A more recent audit of parastomal hernia repairs among the investigators using the aforementioned "keyhole" technique with a minimum of 1-year follow-up found a 17% rate of radiographic recurrence and 33% "composite" recurrence rate - patients who feel a bulge, regardless of their radiographic results. Recently, Pauli et al. reported the results of a novel technique for parastomal hernia repair at the 2018 International Hernia Congress with exciting early results. The technique is similar to the investigators' approach with a bilateral transversus abdominis release and placement of a retromuscular mesh reinforcement. However, rather than bringing the stoma through a keyhole defect in the mesh, it is draped over the mesh in the retromuscular space akin to a Sugarbaker repair offsetting the defect in the mesh and the fascia. Six surgeons reported their results of 44 patients with a mean follow-up of 10 months, with a 4.5% (n=2) recurrence rate, with no reports of mesh erosion or stoma necrosis. Given the excellent early results of this novel approach, the investigators hypothesize that the retromuscular Sugarbaker technique would dramatically reduce hernia recurrence compared to the traditional keyhole repair.

02

Conditions studied

  • Parastomal Hernia

Keywords

  • Sugarbaker
  • keyhole
  • Open parastomal hernia repair
03

In context

Lead sponsor

Clayton Petro is the lead sponsor of 5 studies on the registry; 1 is open to participants now.

Counted across the registry records on this site, refreshed daily.

04

Who can participate

Ages eligible
18 Years and older
Sexes eligible
All
Accepts healthy volunteers
No

Go through the criteria one by one — yes, no or not sure — and take the list to your doctor or the study team. Kept in this browser only.

Inclusion criteria

  • The patient is willing and able to give
  • Patient has one parastomal hernia
  • Patient is willing to undergo mesh-based repair
  • Patient is considered eligible to undergo open retromuscular repair without ostomy reversal
  • The patient can tolerate general anesthesia
  • Repair being performed in an elective situation

Exclusion criteria

Exclusion Criteria:

  • The subject is \<18 years of age
  • Patient has more than one stoma
  • The patient is unable to give
  • Patient is not willing to undergo mesh-based repair due to any reason
  • Patient not eligible for open retromuscular repair without ostomy reversal
  • Patient is unable to tolerate general anesthesia
Terms in these criteria, in plain language(1)

Underlined terms in the criteria open these too. Explained by clinicaltrials.gg, not part of the registry record. The study team decides who can take part.

Informed consent

Before you join, the study team explains what taking part involves — its purpose, what happens, the risks and possible benefits — and answers your questions, so you can decide freely. Consent is usually recorded on a form (the informed consent form, ICF) signed by you or, where the law allows, by someone legally authorized to decide for you.

You can keep asking questions during the study, you are told of new information that matters, and you can choose to leave at any time.

05

Study design

Phase
Not applicable
Primary purpose
Treatment
Allocation
Randomized
Intervention model
Parallel assignment
Masking
Single (Participant)
Enrollment
150 participants (actual)

Study arms

  • Other
    Sugarbaker

    For the Sugarbaker group, the bowel will be brought through the peritoneum lateral to the edge of the retromuscular mesh and then draped over the mesh before bringing it through the anterior fascia medially.

    Procedure: Sugarbaker technique for repairing parastomal hernia

  • Other
    Keyhole

    For the Keyhole group the stoma will be taken down and rematured through a cruciate incision (keyhole)

    Procedure: Keyhole technique for repairing parastomal hernia

Interventions

  • ProcedureSugarbaker technique for repairing parastomal hernia

    The bowel will be brought through the peritoneum lateral to the edge of the retromuscular mesh and then draped over the mesh before bringing it through the anterior fascia medially.

  • ProcedureKeyhole technique for repairing parastomal hernia

    The bowel will be brought through defects in the posterior rectus sheath or contiguous peritoneum, mesh, and anterior fascia.

06

What researchers measure

Primary outcomes

  1. Radiographic hernia recurrence 2 years after parastomal hernia repair

    To compare the incidence of radiographic hernia recurrence 2 years after parastomal hernia repair utilizing a retromuscular Sugarbaker technique compared to the retromuscular keyhole mesh technique.

    Time frame: Two years after the last surgery

Secondary outcomes

  1. Incidence of mesh-related complications

    To compare the incidence of mesh-related complications between the two study groups.

    Time frame: Two years after the last surgery

  2. 30-day complication rates

    To compare all 30-day complication rates for the two study groups.

    Time frame: 30 days after the last surgery

  3. Hospital length-of-stay

    To compare hospital length-of-stay for the two study groups.

    Time frame: An average of 1 week after the last surgery

07

Study locations

1 site
  • Cleveland Clinic Center for Abdominal Core Health
    Cleveland, Ohio 44195, United States
08

References and documents

Publications

  • Turnbull GB. Ostomy statistics: the $64,000 question. Ostomy Wound Manage. 2003 Jun;49(6):22-3. No abstract available. PubMed 12874481 ↗
  • Hotouras A, Murphy J, Thaha M, Chan CL. The persistent challenge of parastomal herniation: a review of the literature and future developments. Colorectal Dis. 2013 May;15(5):e202-14. doi: 10.1111/codi.12156. PubMed 23374759 ↗
  • Carne PW, Robertson GM, Frizelle FA. Parastomal hernia. Br J Surg. 2003 Jul;90(7):784-93. doi: 10.1002/bjs.4220. PubMed 12854101 ↗
  • De Raet J, Delvaux G, Haentjens P, Van Nieuwenhove Y. Waist circumference is an independent risk factor for the development of parastomal hernia after permanent colostomy. Dis Colon Rectum. 2008 Dec;51(12):1806-9. doi: 10.1007/s10350-008-9366-5. Epub 2008 May 16. PubMed 18483825 ↗
  • Gavigan T, Stewart T, Matthews B, Reinke C. Patients Undergoing Parastomal Hernia Repair Using the Americas Hernia Society Quality Collaborative: A Prospective Cohort Study. J Am Coll Surg. 2018 Oct;227(4):393-403.e1. doi: 10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2018.07.658. Epub 2018 Aug 4. PubMed 30081081 ↗
  • Timmermans L, Deerenberg EB, Lamme B, Jeekel J, Lange JF. Parastomal hernia is an independent risk factor for incisional hernia in patients with end colostomy. Surgery. 2014 Jan;155(1):178-83. doi: 10.1016/j.surg.2013.06.014. Epub 2013 Nov 12. PubMed 24238119 ↗
  • Raigani S, Criss CN, Petro CC, Prabhu AS, Novitsky YW, Rosen MJ. Single-center experience with parastomal hernia repair using retromuscular mesh placement. J Gastrointest Surg. 2014 Sep;18(9):1673-7. doi: 10.1007/s11605-014-2575-4. Epub 2014 Jun 19. PubMed 24944155 ↗
  • Miller BT, Krpata DM, Petro CC, Beffa LRA, Carbonell AM, Warren JA, Poulose BK, Tu C, Prabhu AS, Rosen MJ. Biologic vs Synthetic Mesh for Parastomal Hernia Repair: Post Hoc Analysis of a Multicenter Randomized Controlled Trial. J Am Coll Surg. 2022 Sep 1;235(3):401-409. doi: 10.1097/XCS.0000000000000275. Epub 2022 Aug 10. PubMed 35588504 ↗
  • Miller BT, Thomas JD, Tu C, Costanzo A, Beffa LRA, Krpata DM, Prabhu AS, Rosen MJ, Petro CC. Comparing Sugarbaker versus keyhole mesh technique for open retromuscular parastomal hernia repair: study protocol for a registry-based randomized controlled trial. Trials. 2022 Apr 4;23(1):251. doi: 10.1186/s13063-022-06207-x. PubMed 35379311 ↗
09

Timeline

Tracking since Sep 25, 2026
ElapsedEstimatedEstimated, not yet reached

Ran from Apr 2019 to primary completion in Nov 2023, 55 months.

How these figures are worked out, and which studies are left out of them.

Registered
May 28, 2019
First posted
Jun 3, 2019
StartActual
Apr 25, 2019
Primary completionActual
Nov 27, 2023
CompletionActual
Nov 27, 2023
Last update
Dec 4, 2023
What these dates mean
Start.
When the first participant enrolled; while estimated, when the study expects to open to recruitment.
Primary completion.
When the last participant was examined or treated to collect data for the study's main question, its primary outcome. A study that stopped early gives the date its data collection stopped.
Completion.
When the last participant's last visit took place, for every outcome, secondary ones and side effects included: the end of the study. Often later than primary completion, sometimes the same day.
Actual and Est.
Actual means the registry says the date has happened. Est. (estimated) is a date the sponsor plans or expects. It can still move, and the sponsor is expected to change it to actual once it has passed.
No changes since tracking began. The registry record was last updated on Dec 4, 2023, before this site started recording changes on Sep 25, 2026. Its history is on ClinicalTrials.gov ↗
10

Registry details

Key details

Study ID
NCT03972553
Lead sponsor
Clayton Petro
Responsible party
Clayton Petro (Associate Staff, The Cleveland Clinic) — Sponsor-investigator
First posted
Jun 3, 2019
Start date
Apr 25, 2019
Primary completion
Nov 27, 2023
Completion
Nov 27, 2023
Last update
Dec 4, 2023

Study contacts

Clayton Petro, MD
principal investigator · The Cleveland Clinic

Oversight

FDA-regulated drug
No
FDA-regulated device
No
View the source record on ClinicalTrials.gov ↗

Not currently enrolling

This study is completed, as verified in Nov 2023. You cannot join it, but the record below documents what was studied.

Follow this study

Get an email when the registry record changes — status, dates, results — or when someone posts here.

Sign in to follow

Discussion

Questions and observations about this study, from anyone following it. Not medical advice, and not a channel to the study team — their contact details are on the registry record.

Sign in to join the discussion. Reading takes no account; posting does. You choose a display name, and a pseudonym is the default.

Nothing here yet. If you are running this trial, taking part in it, or weighing whether to, this is the place to say so.

Start the discussion