ClinicalTrials.gg
RecruitingNCT07659041Updated Nov 13, 2026

Effectiveness, Patient Acceptance, and Cost Estimation of 3D-printed Retainer Compared to Hawley Retainer in Expansion Case: a Randomized Controlled Trial

An interventional study of 3D printed retainer and Hawley retainer in Orthodontic Relapse and Retention in Orthodontic, sponsored by National University of Malaysia. Recruiting at 3 sites in Malaysia. Open to participants aged 16 Years and older, including healthy volunteers. Per ClinicalTrials.gov, last updated 2026-11-13.

Sponsored by National University of Malaysia · Not applicable, Interventional, and Other

How we know

From the registry’s dates

  • Started Aug 2026; still recruiting 3 months later.
Updated Nov 13, 2026Now RecruitingSite recruiting status changed+1 moreGo to Updates ↓

Help build ClinicalTrials.gg — short surveys, remote interviews or testing, in your language. Take part →

Phase
Not applicable
Study type
Interventional
Enrollment
28
Allocation
Randomized
Ages
16 Years and older
Sex
All
01

Study summary

Expansion of the arches is generally considered highly unstable and prone to relapse regardless of the type of expansion. Retention appliances play a vital role in preserving these changes. Hawley retainer users often avoid wearing them due to speech difficulties and less aesthetic appeal. They are also more prone to breakage, costlier, and require more labour. Despite the relatively recent introduction of 3D-printed retainers, they offer potential advantages in orthodontics, including the accuracy of digitally scanned images, reduced labour and material costs, and improved patient comfort. While 3D-printed retainers are quite new, most studies focus on laboratory testing of their mechanical properties, there is limited evidence directly comparing their effectiveness in retaining arch width increases, patient acceptance, and cost estimation. This knowledge gap creates uncertainty about the optimal choice of retainer for long-term stability, necessitating a comparative assessment of their performance. This study addresses this knowledge gap by evaluating the retention of arch width increases achieved using Hawley retainers versus 3D-printed retainers

Read the detailed description

Maxillary dentoalveolar expansion is a procedure to correct transverse discrepancies between the maxillary and mandibular arches by applying forces to widen the maxillary arch. This procedure is inherently unstable and is susceptible to relapse. While Hawley retainers (HR) have served as the established standard for retention after maxillary expansion, recent studies have shown that modified thermoforming retainers can be as effective as HR. The emergence of computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing (CAD-CAM) and three-dimensional (3D) printing technology has significantly streamlined fabricating appliances and prostheses. 3D printing material is more rigid, with superior compression and tensile strength. Thus, a normal shape 3D-printed retainer may be a viable choice for the retention of maxillary expansion. A recent systematic review highlighted a critical gap in knowledge regarding the long-term clinical efficacy and durability of 3D-printed retainers. Thus, the present study aimed to address this research gap by investigating the long-term clinical effectiveness, patient acceptance, and cost estimation of 3D-printed retainers in expansion cases. This study will be carried out as a multicentre prospective randomized controlled clinical trial (RCT) conducted at Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM), Universiti Malaya (UM), and Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM). Orthodontic patients who fulfil the inclusion criteria will be randomly allocated into the HR or 3D-printed retainer groups. Dental casts of patients will be measured at intercanine width (ICW), inter-premolar width (IPMW), inter-first molar mesiobuccal cusp width 1 (IFMW1), and inter-first molar distobuccal cusp width 2 (IFMW2) for both groups at debond(T0), 3(T1), 6(T2), and 12(T3). The outcome assessor and data analyst will be blinded to the retention method. The researcher will evaluate the patient's acceptance at T2 \& T3 and conduct a cost analysis at T1 post-debond. The findings of this study will contribute valuable data to the field of orthodontics, aiding clinicians in determining the most effective long-term retention strategy for patients who have undergone maxillary dentoalveolar expansion.

02

Conditions studied

  • Orthodontic Relapse
  • Retention in Orthodontic

Keywords

  • orthodontic
  • 3D printed retainer
03

In context

Lead sponsor

National University of Malaysia is the lead sponsor of 124 studies on the registry; 42 are open to participants now.

Counted across the registry records on this site, refreshed daily.

04

Who can participate

Ages eligible
16 Years and older
Sexes eligible
All
Accepts healthy volunteers
Yes

Go through the criteria one by one — yes, no or not sure — and take the list to your doctor or the study team. Kept in this browser only.

Inclusion criteria

  • Patients aged 16 years or older at the time of debonding
  • Treatment plan of extraction or non-extraction followed by straight wire appliances in the upper arch only or both arches
  • Undergone expansion treatment in the upper arch causing an arch width increase of 3-10mm, either using a Quadhelix, expansion with archwires, or URA with midline screw
  • Had pretreatment dental cast
  • Had no chronic medical condition.

Exclusion criteria

Exclusion Criteria:

  • Cleft lip and palate
  • Chronic medical conditions
  • Broken teeth or bubbles on study model at site of measurement.
05

Study design

Phase
Not applicable
Primary purpose
Other
Allocation
Randomized
Intervention model
Parallel assignment
Masking
Single (Outcomes assessor)
Enrollment
28 participants (estimated)

Study arms

  • Active comparator
    Hawley retainer

    A screening will be done to select suitable patients for the study. Only patients who fulfil the criteria will be invited to participate in this study. Following informed consent, eligible subjects will be randomly allocated into one of two groups wither hawley retainer or 3D printed retainer. Fabrication of Hawley retainers will be done using a standardized design across all centres.

    Device: Hawley retainer

  • Experimental
    3D printed retainer

    A screening will be done to select suitable patients for the study. Only patients who fulfil the criteria will be invited to participate in this study. Following informed consent, eligible subjects will be randomly allocated into one of two groups wither hawley retainer or 3D printed retainer. Fabrication of 3d printed retainers will be done using a standardized design at one main centres by one technician using Nextdent Orhtoflex Resin.

    Device: 3D printed retainer

Interventions

  • Device3D printed retainer

    3D-printed retainer Using Nextdent Orthoflex resin Standard design of 3D printed retainer: * Monolithic design (no wires) * Thickness 0.8mm-1.0 mm * Fully cover the teeth and part of the gingiva (1-2mm) * Undercut block - 0.25-0.5mm

  • DeviceHawley retainer

    Hawley retainers have served as the established standard for retention after maxillary expansion. Standard design of Hawley Retainer: - Labial bow (0.8mm hard stainless steel) from canine to canine - Adam clasp on the molar (0.7mm hard stainless steel) - acrylic baseplate (2-3mm thickness) .

06

What researchers measure

Primary outcomes

  1. Retention of the maxillary expansion

    1. Subjects will be scheduled for follow-up at T1-T3 after the initiation of retention wear. During these visits, impressions will be acquired with alginate impression material, and ICW, IPMW, IFMW1, and IFMW2 will be measured intraorally and on dental casts. 2. Calibrated researchers will collect the study models, and the ID and intervention will be covered by opaque tape once they are ready for measurement. Only one dental cast at a time will be picked out of its box without showing any previous measurements. Two dental casts from the same patient will not be measured in connection. Due to the prospective nature of the study, it was inconvenient to anonymize dental casts from the start of the study. 3. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) will be done within and between researchers one week after the T0.

    Time frame: 12 months

Secondary outcomes

  1. Patient acceptance

    Subjects will be given and asked to complete a questionnaire on patient acceptance (see attachment) at 6 and 12 months post-debond. The Questionnaire has been validated and published by (Saw et al. 2025). It uses a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) to ask six questions related to subject acceptance of orthodontic retainers in fitting, speech, appearance, oral hygiene, durability, and comfort. Refer to Attachment 1 (Malay version) and Attachment 2 (English Version) for the questionnaires.

    Time frame: 12 months

  2. cost estimation

    To estimate and compare the costs associated with the implementation and provision of 3D-printed retainers between clinics with existing in-house 3D-printing facilities and clinics planning to acquire 3D-printing services. The analysis will include direct costs such as equipment acquisition, materials, software, maintenance, laboratory procedures, and staff chairside time.

    Time frame: 6 months

07

Study locations

3 of 3 sites recruiting
  • National University Of Malaysia
    Kuala Lumpur, Kuala Lumpur 50300, Malaysia
    Recruiting
    • Fakulti pergigian UKM · Contactasmaashari@ukm.edu.my · +6039289 7741
    • Mei Ling Cheng · Principal investigator
  • University Malaya
    Kuala Lumpur, Kuala Lumpur 50603, Malaysia
    Recruiting
    • May Nak Lau · Contactminalau@um.edu.my · +60379674802
    • Zhang Yi Tan · Sub investigator
  • University Teknologi Mara Selangor branch
    Sungai Buloh, Selangor 47000, Malaysia
    Recruiting
    • Nik Mukhriz Nik Mustapha · Contactnikmukhriz@uitm.edu.my · +6036126 6103
    • Siti Nor Hafizah Salehun · Sub investigator
08

References and documents

Publications

  • Firlej M, Zaborowicz K, Zaborowicz M, Firlej E, Domagala I, Pieniak D, Igielska-Kalwat J, Dmowski A, Biedziak B. Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed Orthodontic Retainers. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 May 9;19(9):5775. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19095775. PubMed 35565167 ↗
  • Hichens L, Rowland H, Williams A, Hollinghurst S, Ewings P, Clark S, Ireland A, Sandy J. Cost-effectiveness and patient satisfaction: Hawley and vacuum-formed retainers. Eur J Orthod. 2007 Aug;29(4):372-8. doi: 10.1093/ejo/cjm039. PubMed 17702797 ↗
  • Naeem OA, Bencharit S, Yang IH, Stilianoudakis SC, Carrico C, Tufekci E. Comparison of 3-dimensional printing technologies on the precision, trueness, and accuracy of printed retainers. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2022 Apr;161(4):582-591. doi: 10.1016/j.ajodo.2021.03.016. PubMed 35337648 ↗
  • Tsoukala E, Lyros I, Tsolakis AI, Maroulakos MP, Tsolakis IA. Direct 3D-Printed Orthodontic Retainers. A Systematic Review. Children (Basel). 2023 Apr 3;10(4):676. doi: 10.3390/children10040676. PubMed 37189925 ↗
  • Saw ZK, Yuen JJX, Ashari A, Ibrahim Bahemia F, Low YX, Nik Mustapha NM, Lau MN. Forward-backward translation, content validity, face validity, construct validity, criterion validity, test-retest reliability, and internal consistency of a questionnaire on patient acceptance of orthodontic retainer. PLoS One. 2025 Jan 3;20(1):e0314853. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0314853. eCollection 2025. PubMed 39752631 ↗
  • Nakornnoi T, Bunjerdjin P, Santiwong P, Sipiyaruk K, Neoh SP, Chintavalakorn R. The Influence of Thickness on the Mechanical Behaviors of 3D Printing Resins for Orthodontic Retainers. Int J Biomater. 2024 Jun 25;2024:7398478. doi: 10.1155/2024/7398478. eCollection 2024. PubMed 38957572 ↗
  • Ashari A, Xian L, Syed Mohamed AMF, Wahab RMA, Kit YC, Tata MD, Sinnasamy S, Kuppusamy E. One-year comparative assessment of retention of arch width increases between modified vacuum-formed and Hawley retainers. Angle Orthod. 2022 Mar 1;92(2):197-203. doi: 10.2319/050921-363.1. PubMed 34797378 ↗
  • Ashari A, Nik Mustapha NM, Yuen JJX, Saw ZK, Lau MN, Xian L, Syed Mohamed AMF, Megat Abdul Wahab R, Yeoh CK, Deva Tata M, Sinnasamy S. A two-year comparative assessment of retention of arch width increases between modified vacuum-formed and Hawley retainers: a multi-center randomized clinical trial. Prog Orthod. 2022 Aug 26;23(1):40. doi: 10.1186/s40510-022-00424-5. PubMed 36018418 ↗
  • Stoev YY, Uzunov TT, Stoyanova NS, Grozdanova-Uzunova RG, Kosturkov DN, Taneva IK. Mechanical properties of materials for 3D printed orthodontic retainers. Folia Med (Plovdiv). 2023 Dec 31;65(6):986-992. doi: 10.3897/folmed.65.e107299. PubMed 38351789 ↗
  • Neoh SP, Khantachawana A, Chintavalakorn R, Santiwong P, Srikhirin T. Comparison of physical, mechanical, and optical properties between thermoplastic materials and 3-dimensional printing resins for orthodontic clear retainers. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2025 Jan;167(1):95-109.e1. doi: 10.1016/j.ajodo.2024.06.010. PubMed 39709226 ↗

Study documents

PDFs hosted by the registry, ClinicalTrials.gov.

Individual participant data

Plan to share: Undecided — Only data relevant to the study analyses will be provided. All personal identifiers and information that could reveal participant identity will be removed to protect confidentiality and comply with ethical requirements.

09

Timeline

1 registry update since Sep 25, 2026
ElapsedEstimatedEstimated, not yet reachedDate before it movedWhere the date was before it moved

Started Aug 2026 (actual). Primary completion is estimated for Dec 2027, 16 months after the start.

Start moved once since we started tracking on Sep 25, 2026: Jun 2026 → Aug 2026, on Nov 13, 2026.

Earlier changes are on the record history on ClinicalTrials.gov ↗

How these figures are worked out, and which studies are left out of them.

Registered
Jun 8, 2026
First posted
Jun 22, 2026
StartActual
Aug 1, 2026was Jun 2026
Primary completionEst.
Dec 2027
CompletionEst.
Dec 2027
Last update
Nov 13, 2026
What these dates mean
Start.
When the first participant enrolled; while estimated, when the study expects to open to recruitment.
Primary completion.
When the last participant was examined or treated to collect data for the study's main question, its primary outcome. A study that stopped early gives the date its data collection stopped.
Completion.
When the last participant's last visit took place, for every outcome, secondary ones and side effects included: the end of the study. Often later than primary completion, sometimes the same day.
Actual and Est.
Actual means the registry says the date has happened. Est. (estimated) is a date the sponsor plans or expects. It can still move, and the sponsor is expected to change it to actual once it has passed.
Status
Not yet recruiting→Recruiting
changed Nov 13, 2026
Sites
3 sites changed recruiting status (3 now recruiting)
Show 3 sites
  • National University Of Malaysia · Kuala Lumpur, Malaysiano status→Recruiting
  • University Malaya · Kuala Lumpur, Malaysiano status→Recruiting
  • University Teknologi Mara Selangor branch · Sungai Buloh, Malaysiano status→Recruiting
Nov 13, 2026
Start date
Jun 2026→Aug 1, 2026 (actual)
Nov 13, 2026
Show all 1 update
  1. Nov 13, 2026
    Not yet recruiting→Recruiting
    3 sites changed recruiting status (3 now recruiting)
    Show 3 sites
    • National University Of Malaysia · Kuala Lumpur, Malaysiano status→Recruiting
    • University Malaya · Kuala Lumpur, Malaysiano status→Recruiting
    • University Teknologi Mara Selangor branch · Sungai Buloh, Malaysiano status→Recruiting
    Start date Jun 2026→Aug 1, 2026 (now actual)
    + 1 other change: verification date

From the registry record's own update history. This site started tracking changes on Sep 25, 2026; for anything earlier, see the record history on ClinicalTrials.gov ↗

10

Registry details

Key details

Study ID
NCT07659041
Collaborators
University of Malaya, Universiti Teknologi Mara
Responsible party
ASMA ASHARI (DR, National University of Malaysia) — Principal investigator
First posted
Jun 22, 2026
Start date
Aug 1, 2026
Primary completion
Dec 2027 (estimated)
Completion
Dec 2027 (estimated)
Last update
Nov 13, 2026

Study contacts

Asma Ashari, BDS Adel, MClinDent Lon, MOrth
Contact
asmaashari@ukm.edu.my
+603 8921 5555
ALIZAE MARNY FADZLIN SYED MOHAMED
Contact
alizaemarny@ukm.edu.my
+6038921 5555
Asma Ashari, MClinDent Lon
study director · National University of Malaysia

Oversight

Data monitoring committee
Yes
FDA-regulated drug
No
FDA-regulated device
No
View the source record on ClinicalTrials.gov ↗

Interested in this study?

Eligibility is decided by the study team. Share this record with your doctor or contact the team directly.

Contact study team

Follow this study

Get an email when the registry record changes — status, dates, results — or when someone posts here.

Sign in to follow

Discussion

Questions and observations about this study, from anyone following it. Not medical advice, and not a channel to the study team — their contact details are on the registry record.

Sign in to join the discussion. Reading takes no account; posting does. You choose a display name, and a pseudonym is the default.

Nothing here yet. If you are running this trial, taking part in it, or weighing whether to, this is the place to say so.

Start the discussion