An interventional study of Apically positioned flap and Free Gingival Graft in Keratinized Mucosa and Dental Implants, sponsored by Tufts University. Completed at 1 site in United States. Open to participants aged 18 Years to 99 Years, including healthy volunteers. Per ClinicalTrials.gov, last updated 2018-09-24.
Sponsored by Tufts University · Not applicable, Interventional, and Treatment
This research study is looking at three different procedures for improving the oral mucosa (membrane) around dental implants. The three procedures will be the standard procedure, the standard procedure with the use of tissue harvested from the mouth and the standard procedure with the use of Mucograft membrane product. An advantage claimed by the Mucograft manufacturer is increased patient comfort due to lack of tissue harvesting from the mouth. Pain and discomfort levels will be evaluated for each of the procedures. Gain in oral mucosa and the visual will also be evaluated.
Experimental Design
The study design for this research project will be a single centered, prospective randomized controlled trial. Subjects will be Tufts University School of Dental Medicine Department of Periodontology patients.
Sample Size and Statistical Analysis
There will be up to 22 subjects in each group, with a total of up to 66 subjects in the study. Up to 80 subjects will be enrolled in order to have 66 subjects completed the study. The calculation is based on 2 point difference in VAS pain and discomfort survey to have 80% power, while setting α=0.025 to adjust for the two primary outcomes (pain and discomfort) which gives 19 per each group. However, considering a 15% drop out rate, up to 22 subjects for each group will be recruited.
Data collected for analysis will be 10 point VAS from subjects' survey forms for the primary outcome. And 10 point VAS from esthetic evaluation, gain of keratinized mucosa measured by periodontal probe in millimeters with stent will be data for secondary outcome.
For all variables, normality will be assessed using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. If the assumptions of normality hold, then means and standard deviations will be reported and the relationship between treatment arm and the outcome will be tested using one-way ANOVA. If the assumptions of normality do not hold, then medians and interquartile ranges will be reported and relationships will be tested using the Kruskal-Wallis test. If the initial analyses are significant, then the post hoc pair wise comparisons will be made using either independent sample t-tests or Mann-Whitney U-tests. When patients are lost to follow-up, their information will be excluded from the analyses. To account for the multiple comparisons, the Bonferroni correction will be implemented. Thus, all p-values less than 0.025 will be considered statistically significant. Analyses will be performed using SAS, Version 9.2 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC).
Tufts University is the lead sponsor of 225 studies on the registry; 24 are open to participants now.
Of its 10 completed or terminated interventional studies of FDA-regulated products, 7 (70%) have results posted.
Counted across the registry records on this site, refreshed daily.
Exclusion Criteria:
Standard TUSDM Periodontology Clinic procedures will be followed. Local anesthesia will be achieved. Center of implant fixtures will be located. Crestal incision thru the center of implant fixture will be made. Implant fixture will be uncovered and healing abutment/s will be inserted. Horizontal incision at approximately 0.5mm coronal to buccalmucogingival junction will be made 1 tooth mesial to 1 tooth distal to the treating area. No vertical incision will be made Gingiva coronal to horizontal incision will remain intact Partial thickness flap will be prepared and displaced apically approximately 7mm from the horizontal incision and secured with sutures. Prepared surgical area will be measured apico-coronally and mesio-distally.
Procedure: Apically positioned flap
Standard Clinic procedures followed. Local anesthesia achieved. Center of implant fixtures located. Crestal incision thru center of fixture will be made. Implant fixture uncovered and healing abutment/s inserted. Horizontal incision at approx 0.5mm coronal to buccalmucogingival junction will be made 1 tooth mesial to 1 tooth distal to the treating area. No vertical incision made. Gingiva coronal to horizontal incision remains intact. Partial thickness flap prepared and displaced apically approximately 7mm from horizontal incision; secured with sutures. Prepared recipient bed measured apico-coronally and mesio-distally. Masticatory mucosa from palate of treating side (Right or Left) harvested according to size measured from recipient bed with width of approximately 5mm at line of measurement. Harvested graft material will be transplanted on recipient bed, lined with initial horizontal incision line with sutures
Procedure: Free Gingival Graft
Standard TUSDM Periodontology Clinic procedures followed. Local anesthesia achieved. Center of implant fixtures will be located. Crestal incision thru the center of implant fixture will be made. Implant fixture will be uncovered and healing abutment/s will be inserted. Horizontal incision at approximately 0.5mm coronal to buccalmucogingival junction will be made 1 tooth mesial to 1 tooth distal to the treating area. No vertical incision will be made. Gingiva coronal to horizontal incision will remain intact. Partial thickness flap will be prepared and displaced apically approximately 7mm from the horizontal incision and secured with sutures. Prepared recipient bed will be measured apico-coronally and mesio-distally. Mucograft material will be prepared according to the manufacturer's instruction and trimmed as the size measured from the recipient and be placed and secured on the recipient bed with sutures.
Procedure: apically positioned flap with Mucograft
Standard TUSDM Periodontology Clinic procedures will be followed. Local anesthesia will be achieved. Center of implant fixtures will be located. Crestal incision thru the center of implant fixture will be made. Implant fixture will be uncovered and healing abutment/s will be inserted. Horizontal incision at approximately 0.5mm coronal to buccalmucogingival junction will be made 1 tooth mesial to 1 tooth distal to the treating area. No vertical incision will be made Gingiva coronal to horizontal incision will remain intact Partial thickness flap will be prepared and displaced apically approximately 7mm from the horizontal incision and secured with sutures. Prepared surgical area will be measured apico-coronally and mesio-distally.
Standard Clinic procedures followed. Local anesthesia achieved. Center of implant fixtures located. Crestal incision thru center of fixture will be made. Implant fixture uncovered and healing abutment/s inserted. Horizontal incision at approx 0.5mm coronal to buccalmucogingival junction will be made 1 tooth mesial to 1 tooth distal to the treating area. No vertical incision made. Gingiva coronal to horizontal incision remains intact. Partial thickness flap prepared and displaced apically approximately 7mm from horizontal incision; secured with sutures. Prepared recipient bed measured apico-coronally and mesio-distally. Masticatory mucosa from palate of treating side (Right or Left) harvested according to size measured from recipient bed with width of approximately 5mm at line of measurement. Harvested graft material will be transplanted on recipient bed, lined with initial horizontal incision line with sutures
Standard TUSDM Periodontology Clinic procedures followed. Local anesthesia achieved. Center of implant fixtures will be located. Crestal incision thru the center of implant fixture will be made. Implant fixture will be uncovered and healing abutment/s will be inserted. Horizontal incision at approximately 0.5mm coronal to buccalmucogingival junction will be made 1 tooth mesial to 1 tooth distal to the treating area. No vertical incision will be made. Gingiva coronal to horizontal incision will remain intact. Partial thickness flap will be prepared and displaced apically approximately 7mm from the horizontal incision and secured with sutures. Prepared recipient bed will be measured apico-coronally and mesio-distally. Mucograft material will be prepared according to the manufacturer's instruction and trimmed as the size measured from the recipient and be placed and secured on the recipient bed with sutures.
Pain and discomfort survey
A survey using VAS scale will be performed from the subjects at 10-14 days follow up visit.
Time frame: 10 to 14 days follow up
Evaluation of full mouth gingival condition (periodontal parameters)
Subject's full mouth gingival condition will be evaluated using a periodontal probe. The following will be assessed at 4 sites/tooth: Plaque index (Modified O'Leary Plaque Index) and gingival index (Löe and Silness 1963). The following will be assessed at 6 sites/tooth: Probing depth (mm), Bleeding on probing (yes/no), Recession (mm), and Clinical attachment level (mm). Mobility (Miller classification) and mucogingival deformities will also be evaluated. Plaque control with oral hygiene instruction will be reinforced.
Time frame: At 3-month and 6-month follow up appointments.
This study is completed, as verified in Sep 2018. You cannot join it, but the record below documents what was studied.
Get an email when the registry record changes — status, dates, results — or when someone posts here.
Sign in to followQuestions and observations about this study, from anyone following it. Not medical advice, and not a channel to the study team — their contact details are on the registry record.
Sign in to join the discussion. Reading takes no account; posting does. You choose a display name, and a pseudonym is the default.
Nothing here yet. If you are running this trial, taking part in it, or weighing whether to, this is the place to say so.
Tufts University